“Sister”ly Solutions: Estate Planning Tools for Balancing Familial Caregiving, Inspired by SNL’s “Sister” Sketch

Disclaimer: This content does not constitute legal advice. You should not act, or refrain from acting, based on the information provided without getting specific advice from your lawyer.


If you are a frequent Saturday Night Live viewer or a New York Times reader, you may have caught the SNL’s recent “Sister” sketch, and if you haven’t had a chance to see it, it is linked here. For context, the “Sister” sketch focuses on several families, each with a brother (“Brother”), a sister (“Sister”), and an aging parent. In all of the families, Brother finds relief in the convenience and affordability of abdicating any parental caregiving responsibility to Sister. The skit even touches on the fact that Brother will inherit the same amount as Sister (as many parents do not like to disturb an “equal-among-children” estate plan), despite her shouldering the burdens of caregiving in their parent’s later years. This skit aims to poke fun at common family dynamics, but for many families these dynamics are not fun. Keep reading to explore strategies available in Pennsylvania to help manage familial caregiving and achieve equity for a familial caregiver.

First, Consider Capacity

When considering these strategies, it’s important to understand that to execute any estate planning documents, a client must have capacity to do so. The necessary capacity is not always a terribly high standard, but many people lose capacity at some point during their life as they age, so it’s important to plan ahead and make sure documents are properly prepared for an aging parent while it is still possible to do so.

The required capacity level for signing a Will is called “testamentary capacity”: a person signing their Will must understand (1) that they are making a Will and have a plan of their own (not their kids’ plan!) as to what the terms of the Will should be, (2) a general idea of their current assets, and (3) who their closest relatives are. The capacity for signing a Durable Financial Power of Attorney or Family Caregiver Agreement (both discussed further below) includes the requirements that the signer understand the terms of the document, the consequences of signing, and the authority being granted.

If you believe a family member may be starting to diminish in capacity, you may want to have a conversation with them about their estate plan and related care plan documents before they are no longer able to make updates.

Powers of Attorney as a Caregiving Tool

A Durable Financial Power of Attorney is a critical document in planning for future incapacity. This document allows the person signing the document, known as the “Principal,” to grant legal and financial powers to another person of their choosing, known as the “Agent,” who can then act on the Principal’s behalf in service of the Principal. Without an effective Financial Power of Attorney in place, if an adult suffers a period of incapacity, their loved ones will need a court order granting a Guardianship in order to manage their care effectively. Having a Guardian appointed by the court can be a time-consuming and costly process, and once appointed, a Guardian has certain ongoing administrative tasks required by the Commonwealth.

Having or not having a Power of Attorney document in place won’t change whether incapacity occurs, but it will change how much say a person has over who takes care of them, and how burdensome giving that care will be.

An often-overlooked feature of a Power of Attorney is that under Pennsylvania law a serving Agent is entitled to “reasonable compensation” for their work in service of the Principal, and is entitled to reimbursement for actual expenses made on the Principal’s behalf. As a practical matter, this means that “Sister” can be compensated for her time taking care of the aging parent, and can be reimbursed for the personal funds she expends to feed, house, clothe, and transport the aging parent if she is serving as Agent under the aging parent’s Power of Attorney. However, the phrase “reasonable compensation” does not specify a certain rate, or any minimum or maximum compensation available. Accordingly, an Agent who is taking compensation will want to keep careful records of the time and expenses they are claiming compensation and reimbursement for, in order to overcome any scrutiny by other family members. Powers of Attorney can also be drafted to be specific about what the Principal thinks is “reasonable” compensation.

Family Caregiver Agreements: For The Most Prepared “Sister”

If the familial caregiving plan is solidified and understood (for example, the aging parent lives full-time with Sister; or Brother and Sister take turns caring for their aging parent or divide up certain duties; etc.), then a Family Caregiver Agreement could be a good way to provide specific caregiving compensation and reimbursement and/or bolster and clarify the compensation the caregiver is entitled to — even if the parent has not needed to invoke their Power of Attorney.

A Family Caregiver Agreement is a contract between the person being cared for and the caregiver(s). While often used in the context of Medicaid planning (to prove that transfers to family members were valid expenses and not gifts), Family Caregiver Agreements can also give clarity to families not involved in Medicaid planning. The Agreement aims to define when the caregiver will be taking care of the individual, the duties of the caregiver(s), and the compensation to be paid to the caregiver(s). When an agreement like this, signed by a person with capacity, memorializes the specific intent for a familial caregiver to be paid a certain amount, then the reasonability of such compensation is much harder to dispute and becomes a documented debt for inheritance tax purposes (see below), although the amount paid to the caregiver is taxed as earned income to them. A Family Caregiver Agreement is also a good tool to set clear boundaries within families and to coordinate different caregiving schedules and responsibilities. This kind of agreement can be very simple or relatively complex and is entirely tailored to the family creating it.

Deferred Caregiver Compensation Through the Parent’s Estate

For both of the compensation possibilities discussed under the Power of Attorney and Family Caregiver Agreement, an Agent or Caregiver can choose to defer all or some payment of any compensation and reimbursements until after their aging parent’s death (note this would not be a recommended strategy if the payment is part of Medicaid planning, and should be done with care for income tax purposes). This compensation, if properly documented and deferred until death, would come off the top of the parent’s probate estate, like any other creditor claim, before the estate is distributed under the terms of the Will. This can be a helpful tool to preserve the incapacitated person’s assets during their life and not disrupt an “equal-among-children estate plan,” but still achieve inheritance equity for the familial caregiver after their parent has passed, in recognition of the work done to care for the parent at the end of their life.

Although it is common for many families to experience inequitable and poorly communicated caregiving arrangements, this does not need to be the case. Having a plan in place can help the whole family when a parent begins to decline. If you want to learn more about these tools or other estate planning strategies, please contact us to set up a meeting with one of our estate planning attorneys.


If you have questions about this or other matters related to our practice areas, please click the Contact Us button to get in touch. We’ll be happy to speak with you. You can also subscribe to our Insights newsletter, where we share updates on relevant topics a few times a year.

Next
Next

The Importance of Maintaining Board and Head of School Relationships